Search JIM Advanced Search

Journal of Integrative Medicine ›› 2015, Vol. 13 ›› Issue (4): 241-247.doi: 10.1016/S2095-4964(15)60178-9

• Systematic Review • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Effectiveness of bee venom acupuncture in alleviating post-stroke shoulder pain: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Sung Min Lim, Sook-Hyun Lee   

  1. Department of Clinical Research on Rehabilitation, Korea National Rehabilitation Research Institute, Seoul 142-070, Korea
  • Received:2015-01-06 Accepted:2015-03-17 Online:2015-07-10 Published:2015-07-15

Background
Shoulder pain is a common complication of stroke. Bee venom acupuncture (BVA) is increasingly used in the treatment of post-stroke shoulder pain.
Objective
To summarize and evaluate evidence on the effectiveness of BVA in relieving shoulder pain after stroke.
Search strategy
Nine databases, namely MEDLINE, EMBASE, the Cochrane Library, the China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), the Japan Science and Technology Information Aggregator, Electronic (J-STAGE), and four Korean medical databases, namely, the National Assembly Library, the Research Information Service System, the National Discovery for Science Leaders, and OASIS, were searched from their inception through August 2014 without language restrictions.
Inclusion criteria
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) were included if BVA was used at acupoints as the sole treatment, or as an adjunct to other treatments, for shoulder pain after stroke.
Data extraction and analysis
Two review authors independently selected trials for inclusion, assessed methodological quality and extracted data.
Results
A total of 138 potentially relevant articles were identified, 4 of which were RCTs that met our inclusion criteria. The quality of studies included was generally low, and a preponderance of positive results was demonstrated. All four trials reported favorable effects of BVA on shoulder pain after stroke. Two RCTs assessing the effects of BVA on post-stroke shoulder pain, as opposed to saline injections, were included in the meta-analysis. Pain was significantly lower for BVA than for saline injections (standardized mean difference on 10-cm visual analog scale: 1.46 cm, 95% CI = 0.30–2.62, P = 0.02, n = 86)
Conclusion
This review provided evidence suggesting that BVA is effective in relieving shoulder pain after stroke. However, further studies are needed to confirm the role of BVA in alleviating post-stroke shoulder pain. Future studies should be conducted with large samples and rigorous study designs.

Key words: Bee venoms, Acupuncture therapy, Stroke, Shoulder pain, Meta-analysis, Systematic review

[1] Park J, White AR, James MA, Hemsley AG, Johnson P, Chambers J, Ernst E . Acupuncture for subacute stroke rehabilitation: a sham-controlled, subject- and assessor-blind, randomized trial. Arch Intern Med, 2005,165(17):2026-2031
doi: 10.1001/archinte.165.17.2026
[2] Lee JA, Park SW, Hwang PW, Lim SM, Kook S, Choi KI, Kang KS . Acupuncture for shoulder pain after stroke: a systematic review. J Altern Complement Med, 2012,18(9):818-823
doi: 10.1089/acm.2011.0457 pmid: 3429280
[3] Kalichman L, Ratmansky M . Underlying pathology and associated factors of hemiplegic shoulder pain. Arch Intern Med, 2011,90(9):768-780
doi: 10.1097/PHM.0b013e318214e976 pmid: 22317937
[4] Seo YR, Jung WS, Park SU, Moon SK, Park JM, Park JY . The effect of ouhyul herbal acupuncture point injections on shoulder pain after stroke. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med, 2013,2013:504686
doi: 10.1155/2013/504686 pmid: 3697148
[5] Viana R, Pereira S, Mehta S, Miller T, Teasell R . Evidence for therapeutic interventions for hemiplegic shoulder pain during the chronic stage of stroke: a review. Top Stroke Rehabil, 2012,19(6):514-522
doi: 10.1310/tsr1906-514
[6] Shah SH, Engelhardt R, Ovbiagele B . Patterns of complementary and alternative medicine use among United States stroke survivors. J Neuro Sci, 2008,271(1-2):180-185
doi: 10.1016/j.jns.2008.04.014 pmid: 18485369
[7] Lee MS, Pittler MH, Shin BC, Kong JC, Ernst E . Bee venom acupuncture for musculoskeletal pain: a review. J Pain, 2008,9(4):289-297
doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2007.11.012 pmid: 18226968
[8] Kim YS, Jun H, Chae Y, Park HJ, Kim BH, Chang IM, Kang SK, Lee HJ . The practice of Korean medicine: an overview of clinical trials in acupuncture. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med, 2005,2(3):325-352
doi: 10.1093/ecam/neh102 pmid: 14212
[9] Park JA, Lee CH, Kwon GS, Lee KA, Jang KJ . The effects of sweet bee venom pharmacopuncture on post-stroke hemiplegic shoulder pain. J Korean Acupunct Moxibustion Soc, 2011,28:37-47
[10] Ko CN, Min IK, Park SW, Jung WS, Moon SK, Park JM, Cho KH, Kim YS, Bae HS . Effectiveness of bee venom acupuncture on shoulder pain after stroke. J Korean Orient Med, 2007,28:11-24
[11] Eom JY, Won SH, Kwon KR, Lee HS . Comparative study on acupuncture, bee venom acupuncture, and bee venom herbal acupuncture in the treatment of post-stroke hemiplegic shoulder pain. J Korean Pharmacoacupunct Inst, 2006,9:139-154
[12] Lee DY, Lee GK, Yeom SC, Kim DH, Kim DJ . A clinical study of bee venom acupuncture therapy on shoulder pain patients in stroke sequelae. J Korean Acupunct Moxibustion Soc, 2006,23:69-80
[13] Lee YK, Lee YK, Kim JS, Lee KM, Lee BH, Jung TY, Lim SC . The effects of bee venom acupuncture therapy on shoulder pain patients in stroke sequelae. J Meridian Acupoint, 2008,25(2):125-141
[14] Yin CS, Nam SS, Kim YS, Lee JD, Kim CH, Koh HK . Effects of honeybee venom acupuncture therapy on post-stroke hemiplegic shoulder pain. J Korean Pharmacoacupunct Inst, 2000,3(2):213-232
doi: 10.3831/KPI.2000.3.2.213
[15] Cho SW, Go KH, Nam JH, Kim MS, Lee SY, Lee IS, Son DY . The effectiveness of Zingiberis Rhizoma herbal acupuncture therapy and bee venom herbal acupuncture therapy for treating post-stroke hemiplegic shoulder pain. J Orient Rehabil Med, 2005,15(4):77-87
[16] Cho SH, Cho HS, Lee KY, Yun SH, Jung WS, Kim SH . A comparative study of the effectiveness of co-treatment with Samgieum-gagam, acupuncture, and sweet bee venom acupuncture on post-stroke shoulder pain. J Korean Acupunct Moxibustion Soc, 2012,29(2):15-27
[17] Walsh K . Management of shoulder pain in patients with stroke. Postgrad Med J, 2001,77(912):645-649
doi: 10.1136/pmj.77.912.645 pmid: 11571371
[18] Turner-Stokes L, Jackson D . Shoulder pain after stroke: a review of the evidence base to inform the development of an integrated care pathway. Clin Rehabil, 2002,16(3):276-298
doi: 10.1191/0269215502cr491oa
[19] Koog YH, Jin SS, Yoon K, Min BI . Interventions for hemiplegic shoulder pain: systematic review of randomised controlled trials. Disabil Rehabil, 2010,32(4):282-291
doi: 10.3109/09638280903127685 pmid: 20055567
[20] Chen J, Lariviere WR . The nociceptive and anti-nociceptive effects of bee venom injection and therapy: a double-edged sword. Prog Neurobiol, 2010,92(2):151-183
doi: 10.1016/j.pneurobio.2010.06.006
[21] Lee JD, Park HJ, Chae Y, Lim S . An overview of bee venom acupuncture in the treatment of arthritis. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med, 2005,2(1):79-84
doi: 10.1093/ecam/neh070
[1] Xin-yu Yue, Zhuo-qi Feng, Xi-yi Yu, Jia-min Hu, Xiao-Jing He, Shi Shu. Fire-needle acupuncture for upper limb spastic paralysis after stroke: Study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2019, 17(3): 167-172.
[2] Jia Xu, Fu-qing Zhang, Jian Pei, Jun Ji . Acupuncture for migraine without aura: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2018, 16(5): 312-321.
[3] Qian-wen Ma, Yong Tan. Effectiveness of co-treatment with traditional Chinese medicine and letrozole for polycystic ovary syndrome: A meta-analysis. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2017, 15(2): 95-101.
[4] Maria T.Chao, AlexandraChang, SanjayReddy, James D.Harrison, JosephAcquah, MiriaToveg, TrilceSantana, Frederick M.Hecht. Adjunctive acupuncture for pain and symptom management in the inpatient setting: Protocol for a pilot hybrid effectiveness-implementation study. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2016, 14(3): 228-238.
[5] Paulo AraujoDias, André Brito Bastos Guimarães, Andrea de Oliveira Albuquerque, Karoline Lucasde Oliveira, Maria Luzete CostaCavalcante, Sergio BotelhoGuimarães. Short-term complementary and alternative medicine on quality of life in women with fibromyalgia. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2016, 14(1): 29-35.
[6] Bosch Peggy, van den Noort Maurits, Yeo Sujung, Lim Sabina, Coenen Anton, van Luijtelaar Gilles. The effect of acupuncture on mood and working memory in patients with depression and schizophrenia. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2015, 13(6): 380-390.
[7] Heather Ann Hausenblas, Kacey Heekin, Heather Lee Mutchie, Stephen Antonb. A systematic review of randomized controlled trials examining the effectiveness of saffron (Crocus sativus L.) on psychological and behavioral outcomes. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2015, 13(4): 231-240.
[8] Marco Gemma, Elisa Nicelli, Luigi Gioia, Elena Moizo, Luigi Beretta, Maria Rosa Calvi. Acupuncture accelerates recovery after general anesthesia: A prospective randomized controlled trial. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2015, 13(2): 99-104.
[9] Kwan Leung Chia. Symptomatic Tarlov cyst and electroacupuncture: More studies required. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2015, 13(1): 58-60.
[10] Zhong-liang Liu, Wei-rong Zhu, Wen-chao Zhou, Hai-feng Ying, Lan Zheng, Yuan-biao Guo, Jing-xian Chen, Xiao-heng Shen. Traditional Chinese medicinal herbs combined with epidermal growth factor receptor tyrosine kinase inhibitor for advanced non-small cell lung cancer: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2014, 12(4): 346-358.
[11] Heather Ann Hausenblas, Debbie Saha, Pamela Jean Dubyak, Stephen Douglas Anton. Saffron (Crocus sativus L.) and major depressive disorder: A meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2013, 11(6): 377-383.
[12] Dagmar Ehling. Integrative techniques using acupuncture, Chinese herbal medicine, diet, and supplements for polycystic ovary syndrome: A case report. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2013, 11(6): 422-427.
[13] Hidetoshi Mori, Hiroshi Kuge, Tim Hideaki Tanaka, Eiichi Taniwaki, Kazuyo Hanyu, Tateyuki Morisawa. Effects of acupuncture treatment on natural killer cell activity, pulse rate, and pain reduction for older adults: An uncontrolled, observational study. Journal of Integrative Medicine, 2013, 11(2): 101-105.
[14] Lu Liu, Ying Gao. Study on the correlation between traditional Chinese medicine syndrome and short-term prognosis of ischemic stroke using logistic regression model and repeated-measures analysis of variance. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2012, 10(9): 983-990.
[15] Zhang-ling Zhou, Cheng-xin Li, Yue-bo Jiang, Cong Zuo, Yun Cai, Rui Wang. Correlation between facial nerve functional evaluation and efficacy evaluation of acupuncture treatment for Bell’s palsy. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2012, 10(9): 997-1002.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

  Shared   
  Discussed   
[1] Chan Chen, Yong-mei Meng , Peng Zhang, Juan Wang, Hui-hui Zhao, Shu-zhen Guo , Wei Wang. Diagnosis and treatment rule of traditional Chinese medicine for syndrome factors of chronic congestive heart failure: a study based on Shannon entropy method. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2010, 8(11): 1080-1084
[2] Liang-ping Hu , Xiao-lei Bao, Xue Guan. Statistical inference and experimental design of univariate qualitative data of single-group design. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2010, 8(11): 1085-1089
[3] Xiao Zhang , Bing-bing Ning , Shuang Ren , Li-jun Zhang , Wen-meng Zhang , Jia-mei Chen , Gao-feng Chen , Hua Zhang , Yong-ping Mu , Ping Liu. Effects of Chinese herbal medicine Xiaopi Pill in preventing rats from dimethylnitrosamine-induced liver fibrosis. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2012, 10(11): 1286-1292
[4] Liang-ping Hu, Xiao-lei Bao, Li-xin Tao, Shi-guo Zhou, Xue Guan. Estimation of sample size and testing power (Part 2). Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2011, 9(11): 1185-1189
[5] Shu Yang, Xin-yue Wang, Shan Jing, Xue Yang, Yi-hua Sheng, Xin Yan. Crohn disease in rats induced by different concentrations of trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid and ethanol. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2011, 9(11): 1242-1247
[6] Kai Qu, Tian-fang Wang, Yan Zhao, Xiao-lin Xue, Xiu-yan Wu, Hua-liang Deng, Lu Yang, Li-liYu , Hong Yue, Qing-guo Wang. Common syndrome factors of traditional Chinese medicine in chronic renal failure based on the questionnaire investigation among experts. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2010, 8(12): 1147-1152
[7] Jia Guo, Li-na Wang, Dong Li. Exploring the effects of Chinese medicine in improving uterine endometrial blood flow for increasing the successful rate of in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2011, 9(12): 1301-1306
[8] Li Dong-tao, Li Fu-yu, Wang Jian, Liu Ji-hong, Yan Nan, Cheng Yong-mei, Hu Ai-hua, Jiang Hong-yang, Shi Feng-lei, Zhang Mei-zeng, Li Jie, Wei Ling-bo, Jiang Rong-qin. A study of diagnostic criteria for traditional Chinese medicine syndromes in osteoporosis. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2011, 9(12): 1326-1332
[9] Song-bai Cai, Xu Zhang, Zhi-xia Chen, Ling-chun Kong, Song-po Wang. Medicated serum prepared with Chinese herbal medicine Zhizhen Recipe down-regulates activity of nuclear factor-κB and expression of P-glycoprotein in human colorectal cancer multidrug-resistant cell line HCT-8/VCR. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2011, 9(12): 1353-1359
[10] Zhu-yi Zhang, Shi-qing Yu, Li-yun Miao, Xiao-ying Huang, Xiao-ping Zhang, Yu-ping Zhu, Xiao-hong Xia, Dan-qi Li. Artesunate combined with vinorelbine plus cisplatin in treatment of advanced non-small cell lung cancer: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Chinese Integrative Medicine, 2008, 6(2): 134-138